Bombay High Court Pulls Up Sena Leader in Doctors’ Assault Case, Orders Senior-Level Investigation
Mumbai: The Bombay High Court has strongly criticised Shiv Sena (Shinde faction) corporator Ramesh Mhatre over the alleged assault on doctors and hospital staff at a municipal hospital in Dombivli, saying that elected representatives are expected to serve the public—not attack them.
Refusing to grant immediate relief to Mhatre, the court remarked that leaders seek votes by promising public service but cannot resort to violence after being elected. It also directed that the investigation be handed over to the Deputy Commissioner of Police (DCP) of the concerned zone to ensure a fair and independent probe.
The High Court instructed the DCP to take charge of the investigation without delay, record statements from the complainant, victims, and witnesses, and provide them with adequate protection. The court has asked for a progress report on the investigation by July 31.
The bench also expressed concern over the initial handling of the case, observing that little investigation had been carried out and questioning the manner in which the police treated the accused. It noted that investigators appeared to have shown unusual consideration during the legal proceedings.
Referring to the viral video of the incident, the judges observed that Mhatre appeared to repeatedly assault a doctor without hesitation. The court also rejected the argument that his age of 73 should be considered for leniency, noting that his actions in the footage did not reflect someone limited by age.
The bench further pointed out that Mhatre was admitted to a hospital after being sent to judicial custody, citing health issues. However, it observed that he appeared physically active during the alleged assault and later left the hospital immediately after securing bail, where he was welcomed by supporters.
The incident took place on July 6 at a civic hospital in Dombivli after relatives of a pregnant patient alleged a delay in treatment. Mhatre and several aides were accused of attacking doctors and other medical staff following the dispute.
Although a magistrate’s court granted him bail on July 15, the Bombay High Court later took suo motu cognisance of the matter, describing the allegations as serious. The court stayed the bail order, calling it inappropriate, following which Mhatre surrendered to the police and remains in judicial custody.
During the hearing, Mhatre’s counsel requested the court to lift the stay on bail and assured that strict conditions could be imposed. The defence also stated that Mhatre was willing to remain outside Maharashtra until the charge sheet is filed.
The High Court noted that the complainant doctor continues to receive threats and stressed the need to record witness statements at the earliest. It also said that submissions from the Indian Medical Association will be considered before passing any further orders on the bail plea.
News source: Information for this article was gathered from a variety of reliable news outlets.
